Meet the Team

A fixture in Indianapolis Real Estate since 1992

David Brenton’s Team is your key to new home ownership. Our combination of experience, knowledge and professionalism will help you get the most from your real estate transaction!

Buying, building and/or selling a home is generally one of the largest transactions people will make in their lives. It is financially, emotionally and physically tasking and requires a great deal of energy and time to get through the entire process. That’s what we’re here for! We’re here to assist you through the process, handle the details and help you in any way that we can.

Since 1992 our team concept has provided a superior level of service for both sellers and buyers. Each team member has specific responsibilities that are aligned to their strengths. Clients receive more detailed attention. The result Meet David Brenton's Teamis obvious with over 3,100 families that have successfully bought and/or sold their homes with the assistance of David Brenton’s Team.

We excel at what we do, because we love what we do!

Team Members

David BrentonDavid Brenton is the founder and leader of the Team. His negotiation skills and eye for the creative solution paired with his experience and knowledge are a winning combination. David enjoys working with both buyers and sellers and takes comfort that no two days in real estate are ever the same. Learn More About David >>

Mary Kay SchaferMary Kay Schafer is a Buyer Specialist. For over 18 years, she has established herself in the real estate community through her strong work ethic and desire to serve her client’s needs. Mary Kay enjoys working with buyers to help find the home to fulfill their housing dreams. Learn More About Mary Kay >>

Sarah SmithSarah Smith is the Office Manager . Her effervescent personality shines through when she is assisting clients. Through her attention to detail and extensive experience in client care, Sarah is able to support clients in all aspects of the real estate process.
Learn More About Sarah >>

Sherry CaldwellSherry Caldwell is the Listing Manager for the Team and has been working in real estate since 2007. Sherry loves assisting our clients with the home selling process and serves as the main point of contact during the listing period and manages all of the transactional details from initial call through closing. Learn More About Sherry >>

Liz NaueLiz Naue is the REO Manager. She works with our corporate clients in the disposition of their foreclosure assets. Liz also assists our sellers in negotiating short sale terms with their lenders and works with clients to manage their residential rental properties.
Learn More About Liz >>

Mark BrentonMark Brenton is the Property Assistant. Mark works for the Team coordinating the outdoor marketing, providing vacant checks for property owners who are out of the area and assisting with photography updates of our listings. Mark’s enthusiasm and willingness to go above and beyond make him a valued asset. Learn More About Mark >>

Kate GodfreyKate Godfrey is Operations Manager for David Brenton’s Team. She provides direction and accountability for the Team as a whole and for each member of the Team individually. Kate utilizes her planning and organizational prowess in defining processes and efficiencies for the Team. Learn More About Kate >>

Jane BrentonJane Brenton is a part time Team member and David’s full time wife. They have been happily married since 1978 and can even tolerate working together. Jane assists the team with her bookkeeping and accounting skills.
Learn More About Jane >>